A federal judge in Boston sentenced Scott Kelley, 52, of Pembroke, a former U.S. Postal Inspector, to 40 months in prison for stealing more than $340,000 in cash from packages mailed by elderly victims of lottery scams, the U.S. Attorney's Office for Massachusetts said in a release. U.S. District Judge Allison D. Burroughs also ordered three years of supervised release, a $20,000 fine, $106,986 in restitution and a $4,400 special assessment.
Kelley pleaded guilty in July 2026 to five counts of wire fraud, five of mail fraud, five of mail theft by a postal officer, 23 of money laundering, one of structuring to evade reporting requirements and five of filing false tax returns. The release is dated Nov. 19 and says he was sentenced the day before. It does not explain why restitution is lower than the amount stolen.
Kelley worked at the Postal Inspection Service's Boston Division headquarters and became team leader of its Mail Fraud team in 2015. The Postal Inspection Service had a crime-prevention initiative against mail scams that began in Jamaica, where scammers posing as lottery representatives contacted victims and told them to mail cash for supposed fees or taxes. Prosecutors say that beginning no later than 2016, Kelley directed inspectors, staff and postal employees to intercept packages identified in that initiative and send them to him. Between January 2019 and Aug. 11, 2023, he asked that at least 1,950 parcels be intercepted. He received hundreds, opened those that looked or felt as if they held cash and kept the money.
The release lists 13 victims, who mailed from $670 to $24,500 in cash. The largest sum came from a Massachusetts man with dementia, then 76 and now deceased. It says Kelley's total take is unknown, but he held about $340,000 in cash in just the last 4 1/2 years of what prosecutors call a 7 1/2-year scheme.
Prosecutors say he deposited about $131,000 across several banks and never in an amount that would trigger a report to federal regulators. He used about $160,000 in cash to buy roughly 165 postal money orders, always under $3,000 a day, knowing that post offices collect identification only for purchases of $3,000 or more in a day. On more than 20 of the money orders he falsely listed two relatives as the payers. He also spent about $50,000 in cash on purchases, including $20,500 on a patio around his backyard pool.
"A badge is a symbol of public trust, not a license to steal," U.S. Attorney Leah B. Foley said. The release does not include a statement from Kelley or his lawyer.
People who think they were victims of this case or of other elder-fraud scams can write to USAMA.VictimAssistance@usdoj.gov. Suspected mail fraud can be reported to the Postal Inspection Service at (877) 876-2455.