A proposed roughly 800,000-square-foot warehouse and distribution facility in Holliston needs a special permit under the town's zoning rules, the Massachusetts Appeals Court ruled Oct. 14, 2026, reversing a lower-court decision in favor of developer CRG Acquisition LLC.

Holliston's Planning Board denied that permit in July 2021. The developer had argued that the warehouse was allowed by right, meaning it could proceed under the zoning rules without that additional approval. A special permit allows the board to weigh effects such as traffic, noise and neighborhood character.

The 18-page opinion in case 25-P-915 describes a project proposed for 72 acres. A copy of the court's opinion is also available through Justia.

CRG's initial 2019 plan included 423 trailer-truck spaces, 170 loading docks and 129 car spaces. The planning board approved a site plan, a review of layout, parking and access, in March 2020 with 31 conditions. In June 2020, CRG applied for a special permit while maintaining it did not need one. It also sought approval of an amended site plan with fewer truck spaces and loading docks, according to the opinion.

The board denied the permit in July 2021 after 11 hearings, citing traffic, noise and effects on surrounding neighborhoods and the town's historical and agricultural character. The board also denied the amended site plan. CRG challenged those decisions in Land Court, the state trial court that handles land-use and zoning cases.

The case turned on a zoning provision allowing a wholesale office or showroom, including warehouse facilities. The Appeals Court said that language covers warehouse space attached to the office or showroom use, rather than a separate warehouse and distribution center.

The warehouse instead falls under the bylaw's general industrial uses, including storage, processing and packaging, which require a special permit above 15,000 square feet, the court said. The panel read the zoning language independently and agreed with the town's interpretation. It said neither the town nor the planning board was entitled to have its interpretation given special weight on whether a permit was required.

The court directed judgment for the town and planning board on the request for a declaration about whether the warehouse required a special permit. The opinion also describes a condition in the Land Court judgment: if the town won its appeal, the plaintiffs would not pursue the project covered by that application. The condition came from the judgment the parties jointly sought in Land Court.

The opinion identifies CRG as the buyer under an agreement to purchase the land from New Hopping Brook Realty Trust, whose trustee, Jon Delli Priscoli, was also a plaintiff.

The decision applied the version of Holliston's zoning bylaw in effect when CRG filed its case in 2021. The town amended the bylaw in 2022.