Johnston voters rejected a Nov. 3 charter amendment on condemnation, 4,761 to 4,090, or 53.79 percent to 46.21 percent, according to the state's election results page. The question, Question 6, concerned an amendment to Section 1-3 of the Johnston Home Rule Charter. The results page showed all 12 polling places reporting.
The vote follows a July 28 ruling by U.S. District Judge Melissa R. DuBose in SCLS Realty, LLC v. Town of Johnston that the town's 2025 taking of 31 acres on George Waterman Road was void. In her memorandum and order, the judge wrote that the town has the authority to use eminent domain but that Section 1-3 of its charter, which says the town "may acquire property" by "condemnation," supplied no fund, no pledge of credit and no way for an owner to enforce payment. She called the taking "ultra vires and ultimately void from its inception."
The town council voted on Jan. 28, 2025, to proceed against the land at 178 and 200 George Waterman Road for a campus holding police headquarters, fire headquarters and town hall, the order says. The town recorded the taking on March 12, 2025, and a town-hired appraiser valued the property at $775,000. The owners, SCLS Realty and Sixty Three Johnston, are companies of the Santoro family. The court record says they had pursued plans for a housing project of more than 200 apartments on the site.
The judge granted the owners summary judgment on that one claim. She did not rule on their civil rights claim and put off the town's own summary judgment motion until after discovery, so the case remains open.
The Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents the owners, said in a Nov. 6 release that the town is now pursuing a municipal public buildings authority as its route to the land, and that the owners' challenge continues. The foundation's release put the share of voters rejecting the question at 53.74 percent. The release quoted Mayor Joseph Polisena Jr. as saying after the July ruling that the town "will continue its pursuit of a much-needed municipal complex on the land." The foundation's attorney, Kady Valois, said voters "sent a clear message" against giving the town broader power to take private property.
The court order said the owners' lawyers acknowledged at a hearing that the public buildings authority law was one valid way the town could acquire the property.