A federal judge has ruled that Providence City Councilor Miguel Sanchez's firing from Gov. Dan McKee's office violated the First Amendment, while leaving damages and his request to return to the job unresolved.
Chief U.S. District Judge John McConnell Jr.'s Oct. 28 order granted Sanchez partial summary judgment on liability for his firing claim against Antonio Afonso and Joseph Almond personally and all defendants in their official roles. Afonso was McKee's chief of staff at the time of the firing; Almond was senior deputy chief of staff.
The case concerns Sanchez's off-duty pro-Palestinian social media posts while he worked in constituent services. He was fired Oct. 27, 2023. The defendants argued that the posts disrupted government work and risked confusing the public about the governor's position.
McConnell concluded that Sanchez held no policymaking or confidential role and that the evidence of disruption did not outweigh his speech rights. He also rejected the officials' qualified-immunity defense, a protection against personal damages liability for officials who have not violated clearly established rights.
Sanchez did not prevail on everything. The judge ruled for the defendants on a separate claim concerning a Department of Labor and Training job application, finding no evidence of an adverse employment action and insufficient evidence connecting the application's outcome to the governor's staff.

