Maine's Supreme Judicial Court has affirmed a Business and Consumer Docket ruling that a charitable trust did not break a 2020 settlement when it pledged $1 million to the Owls Head Transportation Museum.

In Seal Cove Auto Museum v. Sanford, 2026 ME 110, decided Nov. 19, 2026, Justice Lipez wrote for the court that the museum's arguments "lack merit." The court agreed with the trial judge that the agreement obliges the trustees to protect the value of the entire Richard C. Paine, Jr., Automobile Collection Charitable Trust, not only its endowment fund.

The trust and the museum have a long litigation history. The opinion says Richard Paine Jr. established Seal Cove in 1963 and the trust in 1986 to maintain and display his antique automobiles. Under the settlement agreement, the trust agreed to move $700,000 from its acquisition fund to the endowment fund, and the trustees agreed to pay $350,000 into the endowment. An amended relationship agreement, effective Jan. 1, 2021, also requires the trust to give Seal Cove each year the greater of $200,000 or 4.5 percent of its endowment assets, averaged over the past twelve fiscal quarters.

In December 2021, trustee John J. Sanford told Seal Cove the trust would donate $1 million from its endowment fund to Owls Head. The trust paid $500,000 at the end of that month and planned to pay the other $500,000 over five years. Seal Cove moved in September 2022 to enforce the agreement and asked that the trustees seek return of the money and cancel the pledge.

After a two-day hearing, Judge Duddy denied the motion on Nov. 13, 2025. The trial court found that the trust had grown in value since the agreements were signed and that the gift had not unreasonably depleted it or impaired its long-term viability. The Supreme Judicial Court said the finding that the gift did not unreasonably deplete the trust or impair its long-term viability is "amply supported by competent evidence."

Seal Cove argued that the agreement's language about "reasonably protecting and maintaining the value of the corpus of the Charitable Trust" referred only to the endowment fund. The court said the agreement defines the Charitable Trust as the entire trust and uses a separate defined term, "Endowment Assets," elsewhere.

The court also upheld the trial judge's decision to limit the hearing to whether the Owls Head gift breached the agreements. Seal Cove had sought to present evidence about the trustees' handling of insurance, tax returns, accounting and other matters. The court said the museum could have brought a separate claim for breach of fiduciary duty and did not; it expressed no view on whether such a claim would succeed.

Timothy J. Bryant argued for Seal Cove, with Thomas C. LeBlond, both of Preti Flaherty. George T. Dilworth argued for the trustees and the trust, with Susan M. Weidner, both of Drummond Woodsum. The opinion records no public statement from either side.