Providence's permit application for the Public Street waterfront project cannot be approved by state coastal staff unless the scrap-metal company next door provides a letter of no objection, according to Coastal Resources Management Council records. Without that letter, the application would go to the full council.

A council engineer relayed the position from the council's director in an Oct. 8 email to the city. The council's file on the application, number 2026-05-019, runs through Nov. 6 and contains no hearing date, staff report or decision. On Nov. 6, an attorney for SMM New England Corporation, the Sims Metal Management company, filed an entry of appearance in the matter. Six State Signal obtained the file from the council.

Kevin Proft, the city's deputy director of sustainability, told ecoRI News in a story published Nov. 16 that the council hearing is scheduled for Dec. 8. As of Nov. 20, the council's online calendar listed meetings through November only.

What the city wants to build

The city's Department of Sustainability applied for a state assent to repave Public Street, the council-designated shoreline right of way between Allens Avenue and the Providence River. The council's public notice describes public parking, landscaping, stormwater improvements, and a waterfront walkway and lookout, with stormwater treated by a biofiltration system before it reaches the river. The application estimates the cost at $1.4 million, and a city fee-waiver letter describes the project as grant funded.

The council published notice of the application June 3 and accepted comments and hearing requests through July 3. Save The Bay wrote July 2 in support, citing the water-quality filtering and public access.

Two objections

The Narragansett Electric Company, which does business as Rhode Island Energy, objected July 2 and asked for a hearing. It owns the lot on the north side of the street, which is part of a state-regulated cleanup site at 170 Allens Ave.

The utility said the plans extended onto its land, that a planned deck would sit over an underground containment wall and block access to repair it, and that monitoring wells were missing from the drawings. It withdrew the objection Oct. 1, writing that the city had "adequately addressed" its concerns in revised plans.

SMM New England owns all four lots along the south side of the street. Its attorneys at Adler Pollock & Sheehan asked July 27 to be notified of any hearing. On Aug. 26, attorney Joelle Rocha filed a full objection and asked the council to hear it.

The letter said the plans' limits of disturbance extended onto SMM's lots without its consent, and that work on Lot 325 could disturb a cap, containment wall and monitoring wells that are part of a state-approved cleanup. It said waterfront work would affect Lot 361 at the river. It also said the city had not followed the legal process for abandoning parts of the street or compensated abutting owners, and that SMM's trucks need unimpeded access.

The city's response and a disputed deadline

In a Sept. 23 memo to the council, the city's engineers at Fuss & O'Neill said the city had removed all work on SMM's lots 630, 323 and 325 and was not abandoning any part of the street. They said the city was reallocating space for pedestrian access and stormwater treatment and that vehicle access to SMM's parcels on the south side would remain. The memo also noted that SMM's July 27 and Aug. 26 letters arrived after the notice period ended July 3.

Proft made the same point to council staff. He wrote Oct. 6 that SMM's comments were not a formal objection because they came late and should not stop an administrative review. He said the council had told him otherwise on Aug. 11, when engineer Rich Lucia wrote that SMM had asked for notice of a hearing but had not mentioned an objection.

On Oct. 8, after the director reviewed SMM's letters, Lucia wrote that the director had said the application could not be processed administratively and would go to the council unless SMM provided a letter of no objection. Proft replied that the decision reversed the Aug. 11 position and asked whether the director recognized that SMM's letters were late. Lucia answered that the Aug. 26 letter raised specific objections that required a full council hearing.

State cleanup approval

The Department of Environmental Management approved the city's supplemental cleanup plan for the street Sept. 29, a step the city's engineers said the council required before it could approve the permit. The approval requires limited soil removal, a protective cap of at least two feet of clean fill or an equivalent, a recorded land-use restriction with annual inspections, and work to start within 180 days.

It also says cleanup work must be coordinated with the abutting owners, including SMM's Lot 325 and Rhode Island Energy's Lot 489. The cleanup approval is separate from the council's assent, which had not been granted in the council file through Nov. 6.

The council file, which runs through Nov. 6, does not show how SMM responded to the city's Sept. 23 revisions or whether the company has offered a letter of no objection. Proft told ecoRI News the city hoped to resolve SMM's objection the way it had resolved Rhode Island Energy's, but that communication with the company had been slow to develop.

Sources: Coastal Resources Management Council file 2026-05-019, obtained by Six State Signal (through Nov. 6, 2026); CRMC public notice, File 2026-05-019 (June 3, 2026); CRMC meeting calendar (checked Nov. 20, 2026); City of Providence Public Street Waterfront Access Project page. Also reported by ecoRI News.