A federal judge in Rhode Island ordered U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to bring a detainee back to Rhode Island by Nov. 20, rejecting the government's request to send his habeas case to Louisiana. U.S. District Judge Mary S. McElroy issued the Nov. 13 order in the case of Mario Roberto Lima Jimenez.
According to the order, ICE arrested Lima Jimenez in Massachusetts on or about Oct. 31 and held him at the Donald W. Wyatt Detention Facility. On Nov. 4 he asked for a bond hearing before the Immigration Court in Chelmsford, Massachusetts. On Nov. 5, ICE told him, but not his lawyer, that it intended to transfer him; according to him, the agency gave Nov. 9 as the date. He left Hanscom Field on an ICE flight at 3:02 p.m. on Nov. 6 and landed in Alexandria, Louisiana, at 5:49 p.m.
His petition was filed at 2:10 p.m. on Nov. 7. The order says his lawyer got no notice of the transfer and learned where he was only after filing. The government's evidence of his location after the flight was a locator search run Nov. 10, which put him at the Central Louisiana ICE Processing Center in Jena.
McElroy wrote that a habeas petition ordinarily goes to the district where the person is held, but that when a detainee is in an undisclosed place with an unknown custodian, jurisdiction lies where he was last known to be, judged by what his lawyer could have known when the petition was filed. Notice that a transfer is planned, she wrote, "is not notice of where he is or who holds him." She denied the motion to transfer the case to the Western District of Louisiana.
The order requires the government to return Lima Jimenez to ICE custody within the District of Rhode Island no later than Nov. 20 and to file a notice confirming his location within one day of his return. Until then, he must have confidential telephone or video access to his lawyer on request. The government may not remove him from the United States or move him anywhere but Rhode Island while the court decides.
The Immigration Court in Chelmsford has a custody hearing set for Nov. 17. The order says nothing stops him from asking that court to continue it until after his return, and that if it goes ahead the government must make sure he can appear and is not in transit. It orders a status report within two days of the hearing. McElroy left the merits of the petition, including his request for release, for after that hearing.
The order does not state Lima Jimenez's nationality or the grounds for his arrest.

