Two federal judges in Rhode Island issued separate orders on Nov. 13 that keep immigration detainees out of custody, each citing due process. In one, Chief Judge John J. McConnell Jr. ordered the immediate release of Jose Andres Quintanilla Rauda. In the other, Judge Mary S. McElroy barred the government from re-detaining Dannick Gilcisse Massamba-Bankela without a new hearing.

Quintanilla Rauda. According to McConnell's order, a final order of removal was entered against Quintanilla Rauda in 2005, when he was 2 years old. He stayed in the United States, graduated high school and worked in a restaurant, and has never been charged with or convicted of a crime. On Oct. 30, 2026, he was stopped for a minor traffic infraction; after ICE was notified, it detained him under 8 U.S.C. 1231(a)(2). His motion to reopen the removal order is pending.

McConnell weighed three factors from Mathews v. Eldridge: the person's interest, the risk of an erroneous deprivation and the government's interest. He wrote that the government's interest "appears insubstantial comparatively," acknowledged its legitimate interest in carrying out removal orders, and found that neither delay of removal nor release is a hardship for it. He found a Fifth Amendment due process violation, granted the petition and ordered release immediately, allowing a transfer to the Boston ICE field office in Burlington, Massachusetts, if needed to carry it out. The parties must file a status update within seven days of the immigration judge's decision on the motion to reopen. The order says the court does not predict how that judge will rule.

Massamba-Bankela. McElroy's order reverses part of her own earlier ruling. On Oct. 5, she had granted his petition and ordered release and a bond hearing, believing he had not asked for one. The government then showed an immigration judge had held a hearing on Sept. 30 and denied bond as a flight risk. He was released Oct. 5 under the earlier order.

On reconsideration, McElroy vacated the Oct. 5 order but granted the petition on a different ground. She wrote that the immigration judge said "there are no alternatives to detention that would ameliorate such risk" without giving a reason, and that the government's evidence, a three-page printout from its EARM database, did not address alternatives. Under First Circuit precedent she cited, the government must prove flight risk by a preponderance of the evidence and show alternatives would be inadequate.

He remains released on current conditions. The government may not re-detain him under 8 U.S.C. 1226(a) unless an immigration judge holds a new custody hearing where the government bears that burden and considers alternatives, and it must file a status report within five days of any such hearing.

Neither order records a government response to the ruling.