A Vermont Superior Court judge ruled that the Town of Stratton violated a condition in the 1978 deed under which The Nature Conservancy gave it about 320 acres, after the town allowed a parking lot to be built partly on the land.

Judge Mary Miles Teachout, a retired judge specially assigned to the Windham Civil Division, granted the Conservancy's motion for partial summary judgment in an entry dated Oct. 28 that the Judiciary posted to its online decisions library on Nov. 17. The case is The Nature Conservancy v. The Town of Stratton, No. 26-CV-02108.

The deed requires the land to be held "as a natural area for scientific, educational, wood fibre production, and recreation purposes, including hunting" and "kept entirely in its natural state," with exceptions for limited selected timber harvesting and maintenance of fences and foot trails. If the land stops being used solely as the deed provides, the town's estate reverts to the Conservancy, but the deed says the reversion is not automatic. It is a right of entry the Conservancy exercises by mailing notice of violation to the selectboard and recording a copy in the land records.

Between October 2022 and December 2023, the court said it was undisputed, the town built or permitted a parking lot, about 69 feet by 43 feet, partly on the parcel. The selectboard had voted on July 22, 2022, to let the Southern Vermont Trail Association build the lot for its trail project, and voted not to log the Town Forest. The Conservancy mailed its notice of violation in May 2024, and the town replied that the deed conditions are not restrictive covenants.

The town argued the deed was ambiguous. Teachout wrote that the town offered no evidence of the circumstances when the deed was made and no analysis showing ambiguity in its language, and that clearing and leveling the area for passenger vehicles is not related to either exception. She concluded the deed is unambiguous and "the undisputed facts show a violation."

The ruling covers only the parking lot. The complaint also alleges violations from a network of mountain biking trails and from tree clearing for backcountry ski glades, which the ruling says are not part of this motion. The Conservancy had asked for a declaration that the violation entitles it to exercise the deed's right of entry, and the court granted the motion. The entry does not order the land transferred or say whether the Conservancy has exercised the right; under the deed, that requires mailed notice to the selectboard and a recorded copy. The entry includes no response from the town to the decision.