The Vermont Supreme Court on Nov. 13 dismissed the State's appeal of a ruling that suppressed statements and breath-test and blood-test evidence in a felony drunken driving case in Lamoille County, holding that prosecutors cannot extend the seven-business-day deadline for appealing such rulings. The court did not reach whether the suppression ruling was correct.
Kylie Dodds is charged with driving under the influence, third offense, and driving with a suspended license, according to the opinion (2026 VT 53, written by Justice Nolan). On Dec. 18, 2025, the criminal division granted her motion to suppress her statements while in custody, a drug recognition evaluation report, the results of both breath tests, her blood-test refusal and her blood-test result.
The next day the State asked to extend its appeal deadline by 30 days, saying it planned to ask the court to reconsider. The court granted the extension, and the State filed its motion to reconsider on Dec. 30. On Jan. 29, 2026, the extended deadline, the State filed a "notice of appeal" with a certification. The court did not forward it because appeals before final judgment require a motion for permission, not a notice. On Feb. 6 the State asked the court to certify the appeal. The court did so, reasoning that the State's ability to appeal a suppression order is effectively as of right, which would make it eligible for an extension under Vermont Rule of Appellate Procedure 4(d).
The Supreme Court disagreed. State law lets prosecutors appeal a limited list of rulings before final judgment in felony cases, including orders suppressing evidence, and requires them to file within seven business days of the decision. Appellate Rule 5, the court said, repeats that deadline and has no extension provision. Rule 4(d) allows a trial court to extend the time by up to 30 days, but only for appeals taken "as of right."
The justices said an appeal as of right generally comes from a final order, while appeals before final judgment require permission. They noted that another statute expressly calls a defendant's appeal from a conviction an appeal as of right, and that the suppression-appeal statute does not. Missing the statutory deadline is a jurisdictional defect under the court's 1986 decision in State v. Mason, they wrote, so the court lacked jurisdiction.
The opinion says the State's filing came well after the deadline. Dodds had argued that the January filing was also defective because it was styled as a notice, not a motion. The court said that question is open and did not decide it.
Deputy State's Attorney Matthew Dolezal represented the State. Defender General Matthew Valerio and Appellate Defender Rebecca Turner represented Dodds. The opinion does not report how the criminal division ruled on the State's motion to reconsider, or what happens next in the case.

