The New Hampshire Supreme Court on Nov. 13 upheld the conviction of Kaden Lee Covill for threatening a woman's dog with a handgun, ruling that a trial judge could let jurors hear about earlier threats against the dog to show he meant to terrorize her.

In State v. Covill, 2026 N.H. 43, the court called the question of whether that evidence was unfairly prejudicial "a close question" but said the trial court's decision had an objective basis in the record. Justice Donovan wrote the opinion, and Justices Countway, Gould and Will concurred. The case came from Coos County Superior Court and was argued Sept. 22.

According to the opinion, the woman reported to police in October 2023 that Covill had strangled her in late September and had twice threatened her dog. She said he pressed a Glock handgun into the dog's side and threatened to kill it, and on another occasion threatened to kill the dog and feed it to her. He was indicted on a second-degree assault count for the strangling and two criminal threatening counts. A jury convicted him of criminal threatening with a deadly weapon and found him not guilty on the other two counts.

Before trial, the State asked to introduce evidence that between June 2022 and July 2023 the woman and two other people saw Covill point guns at the dog, heard him threaten it, and saw him use his steel-toed boots to make contact with it. Covill's lawyer argued the comments were taken as jokes and that jurors might infer he had a propensity to commit the charged crime. The trial court admitted the evidence under New Hampshire Rule of Evidence 404(b).

The Supreme Court said the State had to prove Covill threatened the dog with a purpose to terrorize the woman, and he had not conceded that element. It held the earlier incidents were relevant to intent rather than propensity, because the woman had indicated to Covill that the conduct upset her, so he knew how she would react.

In State v. Moses, decided in 2025, the court reversed after finding the trial court should not have admitted evidence of a prior assault, which carried a significant danger of unfair prejudice and added little, since the charged act of threatening to kill the complainant while choking her, if proven, clearly showed intent. The court said Covill's case differed: the charged threats were aimed at the dog rather than the woman, and he was not assaulting her when he made them. It also noted that his lawyer said at the pretrial hearing that witnesses described the earlier comments as "always intended as a joke," which meant the trial court could conclude he might argue the charged threats were jokes too.

The court agreed with Covill that the similarity between the earlier and charged conduct created a danger of unfair prejudice. It affirmed under its standard of whether the trial court unsustainably exercised its discretion. The opinion is subject to motions for rehearing and to revision before publication in the New Hampshire Reports.