Providence police must refer eligible youth arrested on misdemeanor charges to the city's Juvenile Hearing Board unless an exclusion applies, under an ordinance the City Council passed July 2, 2026. A police general order dated Sept. 30, 2026, puts the rule into department policy.

Before that, referral was at the discretion of the assigned officer, the board's 2025 annual report says. Police referred 27 of the 148 youth they charged with misdemeanors in 2025, according to the report.

Who must be referred

Ordinance 2026-30, signed by the mayor July 9, covers any Providence resident under 18 who is arrested for an offense that would be a misdemeanor for an adult. That includes youth in state Department of Children, Youth and Families custody.

The ordinance excludes youth charged with assault or battery, offenses chargeable as domestic offenses, and offenses the board itself has designated. It also excludes youth with two earlier referrals, one earlier referral with unmet sanctions, or pending Family Court charges. The general order adds felonies, driving under the influence and cases that state or federal law sends to Family Court.

The chief may submit a written recommendation for Family Court in an automatic case. The board may then decline the case by majority vote if it finds Family Court would benefit the youth and the community. The general order bars department staff from skipping an automatic referral solely because they believe Family Court would be more appropriate.

What changed from the 2021 code

The chief's power to offer referrals already existed in the 2021 code. The ordinance also lets the board or its coordinator offer a referral, lets a youth and guardians request one, and allows referral for truancy. A written waiver of a Family Court hearing, an admission and an agreement to follow the board's decision are still required.

The 2021 text required the chief's approval and let the chief use discretion on simple assault. The new text excludes "assault or battery" without that exception. The 2025 report lists three simple-assault charges among 28 offenses (the Signal's count) for the 27 referred youth.

The ordinance says it takes effect 90 days after passage. Counting from the Council's July 2 vote gives Sept. 30, the day the police order took effect. City Clerk Tina Mastroianni said in a Nov. 18 email that the 90 days run from the mayor's July 9 approval, which gives Oct. 7 by the Signal's count.

What the referral numbers show

The 2025 report calls the board underutilized. It says 205 youth were charged with qualifying misdemeanors in 2024 and 33 were referred. That is about 16% by the Signal's arithmetic, against about 18% in 2025, although the report itself describes the drop from 33 to 27 referrals as modest.

The report says the 148 figure does not show whether a youth had prior arrests or whether the offense was egregious, both of which affect eligibility, so the two years are not directly comparable.

The 2024 annual report says 35 youth were referred that year, not 33, and its chart shows 47 referrals in 2022 and 43 in 2023. A copy of a 2023 board report the Signal obtained puts referrals at 45 in 2018 and 49 in 2019. The board did not operate in 2020, and 2021 has no data.

The 2025 report says that, upon investigating, detectives reported the cause of non-referral was poor behavior or lack of remorse. It gives no count.

A Council release on the July vote says police referred 108 of 508 eligible youth over three years and none on the evening shift. It does not name the years or the data behind the figures.

Gaps in the record

The 2025 report lists outcomes of 11 completed, five pending a first hearing, nine pending a second, two sent to Family Court and two reoffended. Those total 29 against 27 referrals, and the report does not say whether the categories overlap.

The ordinance's reporting section, Sec. 2-378(e), calls for an annual report to the clerk. Mastroianni said the 2025 report was filed and received by the Council on Feb. 19, 2026. She said the 2024 report was handed out at a Jan. 23, 2025, board meeting but never filed with her office, and she could not find a 2023 report.

The ordinance and the general order also require the police department to send the Council a monthly report on juvenile arrests and referral decisions.

A memorandum of understanding signed in April 2025 has Rhode Island for Community & Justice (RICJ) supply the board's case manager through "September 31, 2026," a date that does not exist. It says an extension requires the written consent of both parties. Mastroianni said Nov. 18 that her search found no such memorandum and nothing on an extension. No extension was among the records the Signal had reviewed as of Nov. 18.

The city's online code on Municode still showed the 2021 text when the Signal checked on Nov. 18. Mastroianni said Municode is updated at the start of each year for the year before, so the ordinance will appear after the 2027 update is sent in, which takes a few months.

The board's hearings are closed to the public.

Sources: Providence Ordinance 2026-30 (passed July 2, 2026; approved July 9, 2026); Providence Police General Order 370.02, Juvenile Hearing Board Referral Policy (Sept. 30, 2026); Providence Juvenile Hearing Board annual reports for 2025 and 2024 and a 2023 board report; Providence City Council release on the July 2 vote; memorandum of understanding with Rhode Island for Community & Justice (April 2025); Nov. 18, 2026, email from City Clerk Tina Mastroianni; Providence Code of Ordinances (Municode).