The Providence Zoning Board of Review will hear an appeal on Wednesday, Dec. 9, at 5:30 p.m. over a violation notice for a former Saint Anthony's Church residence at 549 Plainfield St. that both sides' filings say is rented by the room. The hearing is at 444 Westminster St., with a Zoom option listed on the agenda.
The zoning official issued violation ZVN-26-62 on Aug. 24, 2026. The owner, 549 Plainfield LLC, and Ziomara Hernandez are appealing. The property is in an R-3 residential district. The appellant's memorandum, filed Oct. 26 by attorney John Garrahy, says the notice described the use as residential beyond what the district permits and not aligned with the place-of-worship residential use on file.
What the owner argues
The owner bought the property from Saint Anthony's Church Corporation by a deed dated June 24, 2022. The owner's memorandum puts the lot at 26,094 square feet; the city's says 26,446. It says the 7,800-square-foot brick building has 18 bedrooms and 13 bathrooms, 15 tenants and no operable stoves, and that it has been rented since about September 2022. It calls the building a former rectory and says a 1924 permit authorized it as a dwelling.
It makes two arguments. First, the residential use is a lawful nonconforming use that was not abandoned. Second, if that fails, the building qualifies for adaptive reuse of an institutional building, which the memorandum says state law and Providence's ordinance allow by right, and a 2025 state law on co-living housing, effective Jan. 1, 2026, says co-living housing "may be allowed in adaptive reuse developments."
What the city argues
The city's memorandum, dated Nov. 16 and signed by Senior Assistant City Solicitor Sharon Gilmore Garner, describes the building as a convent used by the church until 2022. It says the building has 18 rooming units with shared common areas and no in-room cooking, which meets the ordinance definition of group quarters, a use not permitted in R-3.
The city says the sale to a secular owner, with a deed covenant barring worship use, ended the convent use, so there is nothing to grandfather. On adaptive reuse, it says the building could qualify but must still conform to the use rules of its zone, and that the state co-living law says such housing "may" be allowed. It says the violation could be cured by seeking a use variance or converting the interior into dwelling units.
The board reviews the matter anew. The agenda also lists a continued dimensional variance request at 48 Covell St., a special use permit for Providence Community Health Centers at 232 Cranston St., and appeals by Frank Faltus, Olivia Katz and Chris Borgstrom of Historic District Commission approvals for 56 Pratt St. Comments may be sent before the meeting to athompson@providenceri.gov, and the board asks that they arrive at least 24 hours ahead.