New Hampshire Attorney General John Formella's office concluded that five state troopers were legally justified in the Aug. 12, 2025, shooting that killed David Ward, 57, after an hourslong standoff in Keene.
The 25-page investigative report, released Oct. 15, says no criminal charges will be filed against Sgts. Noah Sanctuary, Nicholas Levesque and Aramus Caraballo, or Troopers Matthew Dushame and Jacob Hunt.
The office reviewed whether the use of deadly force complied with criminal law. The report says that review did not evaluate the officers' procedures or tactics.
According to the report, police stopped Ward's car in the TD Bank parking lot at 194 West St. while executing a search warrant in a drug investigation. A passenger later left the car and told officers Ward had a loaded handgun. Negotiations continued for approximately six hours.
The report says officers twice deployed CS gas, an irritant used to produce tears and discomfort. It describes Ward rapidly moving out of the driver's seat with a handgun after the second deployment. The troopers told investigators they believed he was about to shoot officers or others nearby.
The report also identifies limits in the video evidence. Cameras did not capture the position of Ward's hands at the moment officers fired. A tactical robot transmitted live video from near the passenger door, but that feed was not recorded. Some state troopers experienced camera problems; investigators also reviewed recordings from Keene police cameras and a state police drone.
The AG's office based its conclusion on officer and witness interviews, recordings, physical evidence and medical findings. Investigators recovered 18 rifle cartridge cases; ammunition counts indicated the troopers had fired an estimated 19 to 21 rounds. The autopsy found four gunshot wounds.
Under the legal standard described in the report, the question was whether the troopers reasonably believed deadly force was necessary to protect themselves or others from an imminent deadly threat. The office concluded that their belief was reasonable under the circumstances.
In an Oct. 26 response to Six State Signal's public-records request, the attorney general's office said it would search for releasable recordings, evidence records and a non-graphic scene photograph. The office said it expected to respond further by Feb. 10, 2027, citing the time needed for review and other pending requests.
After Six State Signal asked for any records already cleared for release and for a rolling release, the office said Oct. 28 that it could not provide any records at that time. Victoria J. Moore, an attorney in its Criminal Justice Bureau, said the office had received no earlier requests about the shooting under the state's Right-to-Know law and must first search and review the records to decide on redactions and withholdings.
Moore called Feb. 10, 2027, "our target to provide a complete or partial production of responsive records." The office will try to release some records earlier, she said, "but we cannot make any guarantees that any records will be produced before the deadline in light of the current volume of pending requests."
