A second Concord resident has asked a federal court to stop enforcement of New Hampshire's loitering law, arguing that it gives police too much discretion to stop and arrest people who have not committed a crime.

Robert Gaynor filed the complaint Oct. 8 in U.S. District Court in New Hampshire, case 1:26-cv-00833. The complaint describes him as 42 and without housing at the time of filing. Lawyers with the ACLU of New Hampshire represent him.

The lawsuit challenges RSA 644:6, the state's law against loitering or prowling. It argues that the law is too vague to give people fair notice of prohibited conduct and permits stops and arrests without adequate evidence of a crime. Those are allegations under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments, not findings by the court.

The law covers knowingly appearing under circumstances that warrant alarm for the safety of people or property. It lists circumstances officers may consider, including fleeing or hiding from police, possessing tools suggesting an impending crime, and examining entrances without authority or a legitimate reason to enter.

The law also generally requires police to give someone a chance to identify themselves and explain their presence before an arrest, unless flight or other circumstances make that impossible. Refusing to identify or explain oneself is not, by itself, grounds for arrest.

Gaynor asks the court to declare the law unconstitutional and prohibit its enforcement against him and a proposed class of others subject to it. A proposed class action asks a court to let one or more people represent a larger group; the request itself does not mean the court has approved that arrangement.

In an earlier case brought by Robert Clark, Judge Paul Barbadoro's Aug. 28 order found that Clark had standing when he sued. Standing means having a sufficient personal stake to bring a case.

The judge did not decide whether the law was constitutional. Because Clark obtained housing after filing, the judge required further arguments about whether his case had become moot, meaning that changed circumstances might leave no ongoing issue for the court to resolve for him.

The Clark docket reviewed Oct. 28 lists an Oct. 8 consolidation motion and an Oct. 26 order concerning it. The public entry available to The Signal does not give the order's wording, so it does not establish here whether the two cases have been joined.

Asked Oct. 28 for the state's response to Gaynor's claims and its filings in both cases, Michael Garrity, the attorney general's deputy chief of staff for communications and external affairs, said: "We would refer you to our public filings/arguments with the Court."

Sources

Gaynor's filed complaint; Aug. 28 Clark order; Clark court docket; New Hampshire loitering statute.