A Providence schools report dated October 21, 2026, recommends consolidating Carnevale Elementary School into a renovated DelSesto Middle School building, with a combined pre-K-through-eighth-grade school targeted to open in fall 2029.
The report says Carnevale remains structurally sound and safe to occupy but has settlement at its front section, aging building systems and a former landfill site that requires permanent environmental monitoring. It favors DelSesto because the larger middle school building could hold the combined program without an addition. Expanding Carnevale would require new construction on the regulated former landfill.
The report estimates about $16.3 million to repair Carnevale in place. That total includes a $5 million allowance, a budget set-aside, for cleaning up soil at the former landfill, which the report bases on a similar Rhode Island project. It puts the construction cost of the combined DelSesto campus at about $44.3 million for about 858 students.
Those figures cover different work. The Carnevale estimate covers only that building and includes design fees, insurance and other project expenses. The DelSesto figure covers both schools and is labeled construction cost. An attached DelSesto feasibility study, dated October 19, 2026, lists a total project request of about $51 million. That total adds design, project management, contingency, furniture, technology and a $1 million site-remediation allowance to the construction budget. The study also says a $42.7 million rough estimate and a $37.89 million construction-cost worksheet still need to be reconciled.
The executive summary projects about $500,000 a year in operating savings and attributes that figure to the district. The attached study says those efficiencies "have not been monetized." It calls for an operating and life-cycle cost analysis before they are presented as guaranteed savings.
The report gives differing accounts of what happens during construction. Its student and family transition plan says Carnevale would remain fully open during about two years of construction beginning in summer 2027, and Carnevale students would move permanently to DelSesto once work is finished in fall 2029. It says DelSesto students would stay in their building while sections are partitioned off one after another for work.
The executive summary describes temporary space elsewhere, which planners call swing space. One passage says DelSesto's middle school students would be in swing space for 2027-29 while all floors are renovated. The summary's cost table lists swing space for 2028-29. The feasibility study's schedule keeps DelSesto students in the building during renovation in 2027-28 and moves grades 6 through 8 to swing space for the 2028-29 school year. The study says the swing-space location, duration, transportation and logistics must be verified before the plan can be carried out.
The transition plan's statement that student transportation would be unaffected rests on DelSesto students staying in their building. The report does not reconcile these accounts.
Under the transition plan, rising sixth graders from Carnevale who want to attend grades 6 through 8 somewhere other than the combined school could apply through the district's standard school-choice lottery.
The feasibility study recommends demolishing Carnevale after its students move, under a site-restoration plan reviewed with the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management. It says the cleared land cannot be assumed to be unrestricted. The study calls for additional review with the Rhode Island Department of Education's School Building Authority and the district. It says final authorization should follow confirmation of enrollment and the educational program, an approved demolition and environmental scope, transition planning and a reconciled budget. It separately lists the scope of heating and cooling work as unresolved.

